Are you in a hurry?
Here is a quick list of Beach Hotels in Shelter Island, selected based on their rating
| Name of hotel | Accommodation Rating | Price, $ | |
| The Pridwin Hotel |
8.5 / 10 (61 Reviews) |
From 334$ | |
| Montauk Blue Hotel |
8.9 / 10 (465 Reviews) |
From 130$ | |
| La Quinta By Wyndham Stonington-Mystic Area |
8.5 / 10 (410 Reviews) |
From 79$ | |
| Avonlea |
9.8 / 10 (94 Reviews) |
From 209$ | |
| Home2 Suites By Hilton Long Island Brookhaven |
9.1 / 10 (532 Reviews) |
From 195$ |
Shelter Island Luxury Hotels on The Beach
View all photos
Shelter Island Retreat W/ Outdoor Pool!
View all photos
The Pridwin Hotel
From 334$
View all photos
Montauk Blue Hotel
From 130$
Shelter Island Hotels on the Beach with Balcony
View all photos
La Quinta By Wyndham Stonington-Mystic Area
From 79$
View all photos
Avonlea
From 209$
Hotels in Shelter Island
| Hotel with a view 🔍 | Shelter Island Retreat W/ Outdoor Pool! |
| Hotel with balcony 🌤️ | The Pridwin Hotel |
| Top Service Hotel 🛁 | Montauk Blue Hotel |
View all photos
Home2 Suites By Hilton Long Island Brookhaven
From 195$
Cheap Hotels in Shelter Island On The Beach
View all photos
Inn At Harbor Hill Marina
From 206$
View all photos
Winnapaug Inn
From 109$
View all photos
Kenny'S Tipperary Inn
From 99$
Pet Friendly Hotels in Shelter Island on The Beach
View all photos
Holiday Inn Express Hartford South - Rocky Hill By Ihg
From 101$
View all photos
Sun And Sound Montauk
From 187$
View all photos
The Niantic Inn
From 214$
View all photos
Royal Atlantic Beach Resort
From 113$
View all photos
Seven Resort Style Inn Near Beach
From 270$
View all photos
The Hotel Maria
From 194$
View all photos
Breezeway Boutique Hotel
From 181$
View all photos
The Bentley Hotel Southampton
From 234$
View all photos
Water'S Edge Resort & Spa
From 185$
View all photos
East Hampton House Resort
From 120$
View all photos
Sea Crest
From 218$